Judicial Expertise

An investigative measure ordered by a judge to inform the court on technical matters.

An investigative measure ordered by a judge

Judicial expertise is an investigative measure ordered by a judge (often in summary proceedings, or as part of proceedings on the merits) when a dispute requires the opinion of a technical expert to inform the court on questions of fact. In construction matters, the court-registered expert is tasked with observing the defects, analyzing their technical causes, identifying the parties' liability, and assessing the resulting damages.

The adversarial principle

The expert assessment is conducted under the adversarial principle: all operations (meetings, site observations, exchanges) are carried out in the presence of the parties, who may submit written observations to which the expert must respond. It generally leads to a draft report or summary note, submitted for the parties' comments, followed by a final report delivered to the judge, who alone remains competent to rule on the dispute. The expert informs; the expert does not judge.